Carpet vs. Hardwood: Which is Best for your Home?

Carpet vs. hardwood: It’s the classic decision faced by any homeowner renovating or installing new flooring. And unlike many other flooring options, the differences between carpet and hardwood couldn’t be starker. Here’s a brief rundown on the pros and cons of a wood floor vs. carpet and some other flooring options to consider.

Comparison in Appearance and Style

The biggest differences between carpet vs. hardwood are how each treatment looks and how it transforms a room. Carpet comes in a vast array of colors, thicknesses, styles, and textures, making it easy to match your carpet to your interior design. There is a pleasing softness to carpet that can feel cozy and luxurious. In contrast, hardwood floors offer a much firmer surface but one with a sense of visual warmth and beauty. On the whole, wood surfaces feel more elegant and upscale than carpet. With a hardwood floor, you can always use an area rug to add warmth and visual appeal to a room, with the option to change rugs as often as you want.

Endless Inspiration for the Floor of Your Dreams

GET DESIGN BOOK

Carpet vs. hardwood: Which adds more value to a home?

Hardwood floors win this comparison, hands down. Realtors will tell you that a hardwood floor is one of the features prospective homebuyers value most when looking for a new home. Carpet does not typically add value to a home as it’s an inexpensive flooring option.

Which has a longer lifespan?

Hardwood floors can last for generations — it’s not unusual to find hardwood floors over 100 years old. Carpet, on the other hand, must typically be replaced every 10 to 15 years.

Considering the comfort of carpet vs. hardwood

The soft surfaces of a carpeted room offer a stark contrast to the firmness of a hardwood floor. Carpet feels soft under bare feet and is particularly appealing in rooms where people spend time on the floor – kids’ rooms, game rooms and even living rooms in some homes. However, those who prefer hardwood floors can easily soften a room with an area rug.

Carpet vs. hardwood: Which is easier to clean?

It’s simple to clean hardwood floors. A broom or vacuum easily removes dust and light debris. Mopping with a mild solution of water and white vinegar can remove any stubborn grime. Carpet is harder to clean. You can vacuum away most loose dirt, but it takes a professional to remove stubborn dirt, and some stains simply can’t be removed. Consequently, homeowners find they must replace carpets fairly often.

The best flooring surface for allergies

Hardwood floors are the best option for allergy sufferers, as they won’t hold onto or trap allergens. On the other hand, carpets can harbor dust, mildew, and pet dander. Carpets must be deep cleaned regularly in homes where residents suffer from allergies.

The right flooring for each room in the house

Certain rooms in the home are more likely to be covered with one surface or the other. When considering carpet vs hardwood in bedrooms, for example, many homeowners rely on carpet to deliver a cozy atmosphere and a soft surface for bare feet. Playing on a child’s room floor is easier with a carpet or area rug. The choice of carpet or hardwood in family rooms can also be tough as game room flooring can take a real beating. And while neither carpet nor hardwood is particularly impervious to moisture, you’ll rarely see carpet in kitchens or bathrooms.

Which is the least expensive: carpet or hardwood?Carpet is cheaper upfront. The cost to purchase and install carpet may be one-third or one-half the price of installing a hardwood floor. However, you’ll pay less to maintain hardwood floors over time, and because hardwood floors can last for generations, they are less expensive in the long run.

The sound properties of carpet vs. hardwood

Carpet has natural sound-damping qualities, which make it especially desirable for nursery and bedroom flooring or any other room where quiet is important. Because hardwood floors are reflective surfaces, they add more echo and brightness to a room. Additionally, hardwood floors may tend to creak or make noise as they age.

The safer surface

Carpet is a safer surface for homes with elderly residents and children. People are less likely to slip on carpet, but if they do fall, the carpet and its padding provide a natural cushion. As a fairly firm surface, hardwood floors are not forgiving when it comes to slips and falls. Carpet can also be safer on stairs as people in stocking feet are less likely to slip on a carpeted surface than a hardwood surface.

Which surfaces are more sustainable?

Made of natural, renewable materials, hardwood offers a more sustainable, environmentally friendly option. Carpets are made mostly from synthetic materials, and chemical treatments are used to achieve the stain-proofing and durability that homeowners desire.

Learn more about the benefits of hardwood floors.

At Carlisle Wide Plank Floors, our design consultants can help you explore all the benefits and options for hardwood flooring. In addition to comparing hardwood floors to carpet options, we can show you the benefits of a tile floor vs. wood floor or vinyl vs. wood floor. Our wide plank specialists are experts at understanding your sense of style and helping you articulate your vision for your home. They work with you to select the type of wood, stain, and texture to realize the floor of your dreams.